Blog for HockeyAnalysis.com
Nhl Betting               online gambling     

News, Rumours and Analysis

HockeyAnalysis.com Free Agent Tracker

Should the Leafs do Nothing?

June 30th, 2009 by David Johnson | 7 Comments

It seems that the majority of the Toronto hockey media seem to have the belief that the Maple Leafs are at least 3-4 years away from being a good team and that the best way to get there is to do nothing this summer and hope to get another high draft pick in next years draft. Howard Berger is a prime example as we can see from his latest article, as well as his comments on the radio today.

It’s the reason Burke has to do his utmost to resist temptation this week. A number of distinguished names will be available on the open market, but none will lift the Maple Leafs into the Promised Land. At least, not yet. Furthermore, signing expensive free agents will diminish the ice time required for the club’s growing list of youngsters to prove whether they belong in the NHL.

I understand Howard’s argument that you build success through the draft and player development and there is some truth to that. You can build your team by being bad for a number of years and stocking up high draft picks as the Pittsburgh Penguins and Washington have done. But more often than not, that doesn’t work. See Columbus. See Atlanta. See Florida. See Los Angeles. See Phoenix. Maybe someday these teams will be good, but honestly, can you see Columbus, who made the playoffs for the first time in franchise history, compete for a Stanley Cup in the next few years? Not me. On the flip side, how many high draft picks has the Detroit Red Wings had over the past 10 or 15 years? Their highest pick in the past 15 years was in 2005 when they drafted Jakub Kindl 19th overall and more often than not, they don’t even draft in the first round.

If anything, the NHL in the new salary cap era is probably less about drafting well because talented young players are getting big time money upon leaving their entry level contracts which is completely different from the pre-lockout environment when you could keep your young players relatively cheaply for much longer. The biggest difference in the new system is you can’t afford to make mistakes or over pay players for what they provide. This is what makes Burke a good General Manager. He is resolute in that he has a game plan and he will stick to it. In trades, he won’t over pay even if it is for someone he really wants (see moving up in the draft) and likewise in free agency he won’t pay more than he thinks a player is worth. But there is no reason why Burke shouldn’t try to sign a big name, big salaried free agent so long as he believes that the player is a player who can be a component of a winning team both now and in the future and so long as he isn’t over paying for that player.

The New York Rangers have made mistakes. Signing Gomez, Drury and Redden to such big contracts was a mistake, not because those are bad players, but because they are all making probably 1-2 million more per season than they should be. Had they been on more reasonable contracts the Rangers could very well afford another $4-5 million player which would make them a much more competitive team and might move them from a first round playoff exit to a contender to go deep into the playoffs. If Brian Burke can sign a big name free agent or two for a reasonable contract then I absolutely believe that he should, and I believe he will.





Recent Site Blog Posts

As the Dust Settles
While minor deals continue to filter in and even some bigger names hang in limbo (Tanguay, Biron), most of the big...Thu, 02 Jul 2009

 

Don't Be Quick To Read Into Sakic's Team Canada Invite
Joe Sakic, as expected, was invited to the Team Canada camp in Calgary. So, immediately, Avs bloggers, with pretty much...Thu, 02 Jul 2009

 

Did the Avs Show Major Restraint Yesterday?
The word on the street is, the Avs may have had some pleminary talks with the Chicago Blackhawks about Cristobal Huet...Thu, 02 Jul 2009

 

Sabres sign Montador - 2years - $3.1 million
Well, the Sabres did slightly more than I expected the first day of free agency, signing Anaheim/Boston blue-liner...Thu, 02 Jul 2009

 

Panthers Done Shopping
According to interm GM Randy Sexton, the Florida Panthers are apparently done shopping for free agents, or at least any...Thu, 02 Jul 2009

 

July 1 - Kent Huskins Day
Check out the new podcast about UFA Day here! July 1 has come and gone and as I expected, Doug Wilson wasn’t in...Thu, 02 Jul 2009

 

A Little Anderson/Koci Combo
Here are some YouTube videos from the two newest Avs Koci vs Chara Oct 25, 2007 (Koci get his ass kicked) David Koci Vs...Thu, 02 Jul 2009

 

Leafs Get Tougher - Goal Scoring Will Drop
Ok, so day one of free agent insanity is done, and the Leafs beefed up a bit.  The first signing they made was of...Thu, 02 Jul 2009

 

Winners and Losers
What financial crisis? More than 30 players signed on the dotted line today, including the Habs who spent more than...Wed, 01 Jul 2009

 

Leafs Sign Komisarek - Trade Kubina
The Toronto Maple Leafs have bolstered their blue line by adding Mike Komisarek, and have compensated for the cap hit...Wed, 01 Jul 2009

 

Meet David Koci
This is the newest Av, David Koci. The most I can tell you is this guy is FREAKING HUGE.  Six foot Six, 238...Wed, 01 Jul 2009

 

Scratch A Few More
Off of my list we should now remove Ian Laperriere (Flyers), Mike Rupp (Penguins), and Joel Ward (Predators). That...Wed, 01 Jul 2009

 


Fantasy Hockey

Round 2
Round 1 is over and I finished with a 5-3 record. NJ was my pick to win the cup and I’m still in shock over the last 2 mins of game 7. Glad to see my prediction of Ana upsetting SJ come true and my Nucks get the sweep. Boston vs Carolina...

Round 2 predictions
ok, so i only went 5-3 in the first round but i admitted up front that i was taking a chance on the Flames and i honestly didn’t really believe the Canes could best the Devils.  nobody that i know saw the Sharks mess happening, there’s...

A Rangers-Canucks Final?
Hey, no one would have said that on Tuesday but it sure looks plausible today. Virtuoso performances by the two top goalies to own in fantasy hockey have turned their teams into serious contenders after two games in round 1. Washington vs New...



Poll Question

Power Rankings

  1. Boston
  2. San Jose
  3. Detroit
  4. Chicago
  5. Washington
  6. New Jersey
  7. Vancouver
  8. Calgary
  9. Pittsburgh
  10. Carolina
See the Full List
Updated Apr. 13,2009

Top Ranked Defensemen

  1. ZDENO CHARA - 4301.82
  2. DENNIS WIDEMAN - 4289.26
  3. DUNCAN KEITH - 4153.72
  4. MIKE GREEN - 4130.67
  5. CHRIS PRONGER - 4114.99
  6. NICKLAS LIDSTROM - 4052.49
  7. DION PHANEUF - 4044.01
  8. JAY BOUWMEESTER - 4036.98
  9. DAN BOYLE - 4024.39
  10. SHEA WEBER - 3894.23
See More Player Ratings
Updated Apr. 13,2009

Top Ranked Forwards

  1. EVGENI MALKIN - 4378.96
  2. ALEXANDER OVECHKIN - 4190.93
  3. NICKLAS BACKSTROM - 3975.28
  4. JOE THORNTON - 3890.28
  5. DANIEL SEDIN - 3866.91
  6. ZACH PARISE - 3850.68
  7. JAROME IGINLA - 3832.86
  8. MARC SAVARD - 3737.68
  9. HENRIK SEDIN - 3737.56
  10. RYAN GETZLAF - 3700.47
See More Player Ratings
Updated Apr. 13,2009